Welcome to Sushi Kaito
At Sushi Kaito, we celebrate the art of authentic Japanese cuisine through an intimate dining experience on New York's Upper West Side. Nestled at 244 W 72nd St, our cozy 12-seat venue is dedicated to serving expertly crafted sushi and sashimi, with a focus on freshness and tradition. Our omakase menu, curated by skilled Japanese chefs, promises a delightful journey through delicate flavors and perfect rice. Guests can enjoy a quiet atmosphere ideal for dinner, with vegetarian options and attentive service. Whether you’re indulging in our tender nigiri or pairing exquisite sake, Sushi Kaito is an essential stop for sushi lovers seeking quality and authenticity.
Sushi Kaito: Reviews & Ratings
i had a FANTASTIC experience here - all the fish was so incredibly fresh and well done. the food: you know it's REAL when the omakase is led by two japanese experts - i thoroughly enjoyed the perfectly cooked and temp of the rice, the freshhhhh fish, and the unique yet not trendy pairings of flavors. everything tasted authentic and not overdone. the space: 12 seater, it is slightly fishy inside but i promise you the quality of the fish is perf the service: super attentive and kind
It's solid but not great. It's budget friendly but not very memorable. I wouldn't go there again
The attention and effort to detail created an outstanding experience whether it be the delicacy of the nigiri, the seating of guests, the focus and concentration of the chefs, and attentive consideration of the host. Highly recommended
It's a small spot that seats about 10 people so it's nice and quiet. The sushi was amazing and really fresh. It was 17 courses for $115 so great price for the quality it was. You can also order repeats of any that you liked.
Incredible local omakase! Great price and wonderfully fresh! Almost don't want to post because will get more difficult to get a reservation. Can't miss and always a stop for me when back in NYC!
Had the pleasure to get a spot at the counter last night and enjoyed their omakase menu. From the opening pieces to the last, it was a delight to taste fresh and perfectly seasoned bites through their versatile and interesting menu. The kamatoro, tuna jaw, below me away and had to get a second piece. I'll be back.
I think Sushi Kaito might be my all-time favorite higher end sushi place in NYC. I've been lucky enough to try a handful of Michelin starred places in NYC like Sushi Yasuda, Kosaka and Noz. Places with Michelin recognition are generally good (with the exception of Nakazawa which was pretty disappointing.) Sushi Kaito is a hidden gem and while it doesn't have a Michelin star, I think that the food and service here is better than most other places in the city. In addition, it's a little more reasonable pricewise since it doesn't have any Michelin stars. FYI you will need to book a reservation in advance. There are only 10 seats. The presentation is great, and while I've only been here twice, both times I've felt that the meal was a different experience. All of the fish is extremely fresh which is an expectation at this kind of restaurant and the preparation is unique. The pacing is also very good and you're not made to feel rushed or feel like you have to wait for each piece. This most recent visit they had my favorite, nodoguro. This fish is in season during the colder months and not available all year round. In short, if you're looking for a sushi place for a special occasion, skip the typical places and give Sushi Kaito a shot. You won't be disappointed.
Location
-
244 W 72nd St, New York, NY 10023 Hotline: (212) 799-1278
Welcome to Sushi Kaito: a hidden gem nestled in the heart of the Upper West Side at 244 W 72nd St, New York, NY 10023. This intimate sushi haven brings the essence of Japan to life with an impressive menu that showcases the finest in fresh seafood, all served with a side of warmth and genuine hospitality.
As you step through the doors of Sushi Kaito, you’ll find a cozy atmosphere that seats around 12 guests, making it an ideal spot for a serene dining experience. The quiet ambiance sets the tone for an unforgettable night of culinary exploration. Whether you’re looking for a cozy dinner date or a family outing, Sushi Kaito caters to all with its inclusive offerings, including vegetarian options and kid-friendly choices.
House Specials:
- Kaito's Blue Fin Tuna Donburi: Savor the delicate flavors of Blue Fin tuna sashimi and perfectly cooked sliced egg over sushi rice, served with warming red miso soup. Priced at $30.00, it's an experience that promises to be as delightful as it sounds.
- Kaito's Hamachi Yellowtail Donburi: For just $32.00, indulge in the rich taste of yellowtail sashimi, complimented by the same affordance of sushi rice and miso soup—a true representation of authentic Japanese cuisine.
Sushi enthusiasts will appreciate the well-curated a la carte menu, featuring standout options like the BF OhToro and BF Akami Tuna, each prepared with precision and care. The appetizers, including the flavorful ChamaMe Brown Soybean and the refreshing Seaweed Salad dressed with ponzu sauce, set the stage for a remarkable dining experience.
Exceptional Reviews: Diners rave about the freshness of the fish and the meticulous attention given to each dish by skilled chefs. For example, Joanne H. praises the superb quality of the omakase, highlighting the perfectly cooked rice and unique flavor pairings that convey authenticity without pretension. Similarly, Tommy C. appreciates the 17-course experience at an unbeatable price, emphasizing the exceptional freshness that Sushi Kaito represents.
It's important to note, however, that with such acclaim, reservations are highly recommended—this cozy eatery fills up quickly! Alongside the culinary offerings, guests can enjoy various utilities such as outdoor seating and the accessibility of credit card payments, including cryptocurrency options. The inclusion of gender-neutral restrooms and facilities for pets further exemplifies Sushi Kaito's commitment to inclusivity.
Final Thoughts: With its intimate setting, expertly crafted dishes, and warm service, Sushi Kaito is truly a standout among Japanese dining establishments in New York City. Be sure to secure a reservation and prepare for a dining experience that captivates both the palate and the heart.
